Defending a layered case

Work towards the goal in this scripted conversation. Reply in your own words. Hints are optional; replies are not graded.

Your conversation goal

Defend a multi-layered position under challenge by conceding proportionately, ranking reasons, and showing why the conclusion survives credible objections.

In English, defend a complex position by conceding one limitation, ranking two supporting reasons, and stating precisely what conclusion remains.

Choose a position you still hold even though you accept a serious objection to one part of it.